Good Old Collingwood Forever

The Story of Collingwood's 1953 Premiership

Round 2 – North Melbourne Vs Collingwood

leave a comment »

May 2, 1953

North Melbourne dominated the round 2 clash with Collingwood

Going into the round 2 clash against North Melbourne at Arden Street Collingwood was missing their full-forward Bill Twomey who had sustained an injury in the exhibition match against Fitzroy a week earlier. (1) Also out injured was Collingwood’s centre-half-forward Maurice ‘Mocha’ Dunstan, which ultimately caused problems for the Magpies’ forward line. (2) North Melbourne’s Jock Spencer was also out of the match, playing in the reserves after being  injured preseason. (3)

North Melbourne thrashed the Magpies by 43 points. Collingwood were never in the match with the Kangaroos being too quick and tough for the Magpies. (4) They outclassed the Magpies with an all-round flawless display that made a shocked Collingwood look second rate. (5) The only two Collingwood players to show any initiative on the day were rovers Lou Richards and Bob Rose, (6) although Rose never looked dangerous whilst roving,  he much looked better while resting in the forward pocket where he kicked two goals. (7) Unfortunately injury forced the Magpie skipper Lou Richards from the ground at half-time and he was not able to come back onto the field. (8) His loss came at a critical stage in the game and contributed to the defeat. (9) He had kicked three of the Magpies’ five goals up until that stage. Jack Hamilton at full-back was well beaten by North’s stop-gap full-forward Gerald Marchesi. (10)

The speedy Allan Aylett demoralised the Collingwood defence (11) kicking two goals in the second quarter (12), while a powerless Collingwood put on a deplorable display in which they all too often spoilt each other while marking and collided into each other on the ground. (13) Many Collingwood players were too reckless when going into packs, whilst North Melbourne were much too strong, which enabled them to trade bumps with the Magpies whilst still retaining their devastating pace and teamwork. (14)

Team

1st Quarter

2nd Quarter

3rd Quarter

Final Score

North Melbourne

5.2.32 10.5.65 14.7.91 18.10.118

Collingwood

3.1.19 5.5.35 7.8.50 11.9.75

Goals

North Melbourne – Brady 4, Marchesi 4, Aylett 4, Grambeau 3

Collingwood – B. Rose 2, L. Richards 3, Batchelor 3

Best

North Melbourne – Parkes, Aylett, O’ Halloran, Brooker, Hamilton, Brady

Collingwood – Finck, Mann, B. Rose, Kingston, Batchelor, M. Twomey

Around the Grounds

Carlton recorded their first win of the season defeating the hapless Melbourne. Geelong were much too strong for Footscray defeating them by 41points, with Trezise kicking 8 goals and Goninon 3 for the Cats, cementing their place at the top of the VFL ladder. John Coleman kicked 11 of Essendon’s 13 goals in their 10 point loss to the Swans, while Fitzroy recorded a 1 point victory over Richmond, with Joe Hickey kicking 6 goals for the Gorillas.

Ladder After Round 2

Team

Win

Draw

Lose

Points For

Points Against

Percentage

Premiership Points

Geelong

2 0 0 180 99 190.9 8

North Melbourne

2 0 0 233 132 168.9 8

Carlton

1 0 1 150 124 121.0 4

Essendon

1 0 1 200 187 107.0 4

Richmond

1 0 1 153 148 103.4 4

Collingwood

1 0 1 193 195 99.0 4

St Kilda

1 0 1 149 162 92.0 4

Fitzroy

1 0 1 169 101 88.5 4

South Melbourne

1 0 1 176 207 85.0 4

Footscray

1 0 1 128 163 77.8 4

Melbourne

0 0 2 126 163 77.3 0

Hawthorn

0 0 2 95 179 53.1 0

Goalkickers

Player

Team

Goals in Round

Goals For Season

J. Coleman Essendon 11 21
N. Trezise Geelong 8 12
B. Twomey Collingwood 0 9
J. Hickey Fitzroy 6 9
A. Aylett North Melbourne 4 8
G. Goninon Geelong 3 7
G. Marchesi North Melbourne 4 6
P. Cash Hawthorn 4 6

In other news

It is quite interesting reading the old newspaper reports of the matches and seeing the different styles that each journalist/commentator uses while writing their match report. One thing I found odd was that twice in his article on this match, the Herald’s Alf Brown referred to North as Melbourne. I guess this was a mistake on behalf of the editor and shows the perils with trying to get the paper out in the evening after the conclusion of the match. This is something that is not so much of a problem these days as there are no longer any ‘evening editions’ of the Melbourne newspapers.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Footnotes

  1. Reynolds. D & Buggy. H – The Argus – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 13
  2. Reynolds. D & Buggy. H – The Argus – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 13
  3. Reynolds. D & Buggy. H – The Argus – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 13
  4. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
  5. Brown. A – The Herald – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 25
  6. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
  7. The Age – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 7
  8. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
  9. The Age – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 7
  10. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
  11. Brown. A – The Herald – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 25
  12. Brown. A – The Herald – Saturday May 2, 1953 – page 25
  13. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
  14. Bickford. G – The Argus – Monday May 4, 1953 – page 10
    Advertisements

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: